top of page

Pre-orders open through November 15. Pickup begins November 17.

LIMITED SEASONAL RELEASE

Mullen's Ice Cream Advent Calendar

Back for 2026 and now available to order online!

 

Twelve half pints of small batch ice cream, made by hand in Watertown since 1932. Best sellers, holiday classics, and a few flavors we make once a year.

 

Pickup only, at our Watertown and Oconomowoc shops.

$70

Pre-order price

$60

through November 15

How many boxes?

Please choose a pickup shop and day before adding to your cart.

Limited boxes made. Will sell out fast.

Pickup only, available at the Watertown and Oconomowoc locations

Twelve flavors.

Best sellers, holiday classics, and a few we make once a year. Every lid is numbered and labeled, so there’s something to look forward to every day.​

​

The flavors, in order

01

DIRT CAKE

Sweet cream with Oreo cookie pieces, devil's food cake and buttercream frosting.

05

PUMPKIN CHEESECAKE

Pumpkin and cream cheese with pumpkin pie spice

09

BRANDY OLD FASHIONED

Brandy, cherries, orange and Angostura bitters.​

02

WEDDING CAKE

White cake and sprinkles with a touch of almond.

 

06

HIGHLANDER GROGG

Ground roasted coffee bean, and nothing else.

10

HOT CHOCOLATE

A chocolate syrup flavored base with vanilla and marshmallow swirl

 

03

DOUBLE DOUGH

Cookie dough and dark chocolate fudge brownie.

​

07

CINNAMON ROLL

Cinnamon and brown sugar with danish dough and cream cheese frosting.

11

PEPPERMINT MOCHA

Cocoa and coffee with peppermint candy.

04

CHERRY CHIP

Cherries and chocolate chips.

​

08

MINT OREO

Mint with Oreo cookie pieces throughout.

12

GINGERBREAD

Gingersnap and warm spice with marshmallow

​

How it works

Step1

Order online

Pre-orders are open through November 15.

Step 2

Choose your shop and your day

Pick up in Watertown or Oconomowoc on the day that works for you.

Step 3

Open one a day

Make each day a little sweeter, one pint at a time.

Where and when to pick it up

Choose your shop and your pickup day when you order.  There is no time slot, just a day.

Watertown

November 17-25 & 27-29

Closed Monday, November 23.

212 W Main St Watertown, WI 53094

Pickup hours: 11AM - 8PM

Oconomowoc

November 27, 28 & 29 only

During the German Christmas Market.

120 E Wisconsin Ave Oconomowoc, WI 53066

Pickup hours: 12 PM - 6 PM

Pickup only. No shipping this year.

Each shop has a limit of 100 boxes per available pickup day. Choose your location and date when ordering; no time slot is required.

Sold out in 2025

Our 2025 run sold out. We're making another limited batch this year, so get yours early.

"Oh I would drive states away for this."

Mercedez D.

"I want to pre order the advent calendar ice cream, I’ll take 2 please!"

Stacey H.

"This would be the best Christmas gift."

Cooper A.

“Love this! A gift the whole family can share. It’s a perfect holiday experience.”

Quinn C.

Ice Cream Cone.jpg

Made in Watertown since 1932

Mullen's has been making ice cream in the same Watertown shop for more than ninety years, in small batches, by hand, for families who have been coming back for generations. The advent calendar is the one time a year the kitchen makes a dozen seasonal flavors at once. Some of them show up only in this box.

A few things before you order.

An exclusive holiday drop, made once a year.

Pre-orders close November 15.

Mullen's Ice Cream Advent Calendar

Mullen's Ice Cream Advent Calendar

$60.00Price
Quantity
Back for 2026 and now available to order online!
 
Twelve half pints of small batch ice cream, made by hand in Watertown since 1932. Best sellers, holiday classics, and a few flavors we make once a year.
 
Pickup only, at our Watertown and Oconomowoc shops.
bottom of page